Talk:Ruled by Secrecy (song)

MuseWiki, wiki for the band Muse
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Should Sergei Rachmaninov be credited as a writer of this song ? I personally think we should leave his name on Space Dementia's writer box thing followed by (partial) or something, because Matt quotes his music quite a bit throughout that song. User:M3cky 09:54 16 March 2008 (GMT +8)

Personally I don't see why he should be any different to all the other composers and songwriters which have phrases that are all but identical to those Matt Bellamy writes. I think notes pointing out the similarities, with inline references (i.e. written not cited), to the relevant sections of the songs' and similar pieces' scores would be quite sufficient, along with the obvious (spurious) reasoning that he may have unintentionally drawn from memory parts of those pieces he has listened to. --Tene 05:57, 16 March 2008 (GMT)
Fair enough, I was a bit concerned with Matan's adding of Rachmaninov as a writer for megalomania, space dementia and this song :)
User:M3cky 15:44 16 March 2008 (GMT +8)